The Paradox of Democratic Erosion ๐๐๏ธ๐ฑ
Undermining democracy in the name of saving it
In this episode, we explore the research of Alia Braley, a PhD candidate at UC Berkeley, who sheds light on the surprising reasons why even those who value democracy might contribute to its decline. By manipulating perceptions about their opponent's commitment to democratic norms, Braley's research reveals a transformative finding: when partisans are made aware that their rivals are more committed to democratic principles than previously believed, their own dedication to upholding these norms increases significantly. This opens up a fascinating avenue for understanding how political narratives, accusations, and misinformation can potentially fuel democratic backsliding.
"Democrats estimate Republicans support for political violence at levels that are three, four hundred percent higher than they really are, and it's pretty much the same for Republicans perceiving Democrats support for violence."
The Perception Gap and Democratic Backsliding
Democratic backsliding refers to the gradual weakening of democratic norms and institutions, rather than a violent overthrow. In the United States, as in many other countries, there is high support for democracy across the political spectrum. However, the perception gap between Democrats and Republicans regarding the other side's commitment to democratic norms is significant. Democrats tend to overestimate Republicans' support for political violence, while Republicans overestimate Democrats' support for the same. This perception gap creates a paradoxical situation where individuals may act against their own interests and support candidates who undermine democracy in the name of saving it.
The Role of Propaganda and Fear
One of the key factors contributing to the perception gap is propaganda. Political leaders on both sides use fear-mongering tactics to convince their supporters that the other side is a threat to democracy. By stoking fears, these leaders create a sense of urgency and justify actions that undermine democratic norms. This fear-based approach leads individuals to believe that they are in a "gunfight" and must fight fire with fire. However, when individuals are presented with corrective information that challenges their misperceptions, they are more likely to ratchet down their support for political violence.
"There is this area where on core democratic issues that Republicans and Democrats largely seem to support, even from the far left to the far right in a lot of cases."
Overcoming the Perception Gap
To bridge the perception gap and prevent democratic erosion, it is crucial to build trust and foster a shared understanding of democratic norms. One approach is to use third-party guarantees or costly signals of good faith. These mechanisms can provide reassurance and help individuals see that their opponents are more committed to democracy than they previously believed. Additionally, educational initiatives that highlight the hard work and dedication of election workers can help restore faith in the democratic process.
Controversy Surrounding Symmetrical Findings
Alia Braley's research has stirred up controversy due to its reporting of some symmetrical findings regarding support for democratic norms among Republicans and Democrats. Despite presenting data illustrating similar levels of commitment to democracy across party lines, Braley has faced significant pushback, particularly from critics who argue that the actions of figures like Donald Trump undermine the notion of symmetrical support. This dissent highlights the polarized nature of contemporary political discourse, with some going so far as to accuse the research of promoting partisan agendas.
To delve deeper into the fascinating insights uncovered by Alia Braley's research and discover how to combat democratic backsliding, tune in to our latest episode now. Gain valuable insights into the transformative power of correcting misperceptions and learn how we can collectively work towards safeguarding democratic norms. Don't miss out on this essential discussion.
New This Week in Outrage Episode!
Itโs everything the Outrage Overload podcast is not. Itโs not edited. Itโs not scripted. Itโs lightly researched. Itโs David and Lisa talking about this week in outrage, what was in the news, in the memes, and maybe finding some backstory with a humorous (at least to us) twist.