4 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Brianna J. Migliore's avatar

I appreciate this piece, and I think you’re right that much of our current polarization is fueled by distorted perceptions of the “other side,” and that people often say they want unity but really mean they want others to come around to their view.

Where I can’t get on board with this, though, is the framing of “unacceptable ideas.” There’s an important difference between disagreements over values or policy and rejecting shared reality or the basic rules of democracy. Equating something like DEI with the legitimacy of elections is a false equivalence. One is a policy debate, while the other is a foundational condition for democracy to function. A democratic system depends on some baseline agreement about reality and underlying laws, norms, and processes. Without that, there isn’t really a system left to unify within.

This is similar to Karl Popper’s paradox of tolerance. A tolerant society has to reject intolerant ideas that undermine the conditions that make tolerance possible. In the same way, a democratic system has to reject claims that undermine its own foundations. So the paradox isn’t that we refuse unity. It’s that some forms of “unity” would require accepting the breakdown of the system that makes unity possible in the first place. You may be circling this point, but framing DEI and election legitimacy as equivalent comes across as treating foundational democratic boundaries as just another partisan preference.

You write that unity may require “accepting a version of peace…where we decide that the relationship is more important than the ‘common-sense baseline’ we’ve spent so long defending.” That seems to be implying that if we want to reduce polarization and build bridges, we should be prioritizing unity even when it requires accepting views that undermine the foundations of democracy. I strongly disagree with that, and framing those boundaries as partisan or as part of the problem feels like a dangerous direction to take.

Outrage Overload's avatar

Thanks for reading the article and taking the time for the thoughtful comments. I agree with much of what you're saying, and have said as much in other articles here and on the podcast. You're getting to the very heart of the "bridge-building" tensions I’ve been exploring, along with others in the community/movement.

I’ve argued in other contexts that when we see clear alarms being sounded by constitutional experts and democracy monitors, dismissing those concerns as "just another opinion" is a form of gaslighting. A functioning democracy does require a baseline agreement on the rules of the game.

I'll probably be writing more about this and I have a couple of adjacent articles in the works.

When I use the term “unacceptable ideas” here, I am not attempting to create a moral equivalence between them. Instead, I’m looking at their "social function." In that sense, these two categories (and one could probably name many others) act as functional equivalents because they both serve as the "red lines" where the "unity tent" collapses for a segment of the population. Whether it’s a factual disagreement or a deep moral one, the psychological result is the same: a refusal to concede space to the other side.

Pearce Godwin of the Listen First Project has said he's willing to sacrifice democracy for peace. For him, "the even greater risk and danger than losing democracy (which I cherish), is losing the peace." I draw the line differently, but that’s really the core of the “Unity Paradox”: Where and how we draw these lines and the fact that the lines exist at all.

As a thought experiment, how do we deal with a flat earther? We don’t see our refusal to validate their worldview as an act of dominance; we see it as an act of sanity. But to the flat earther, our 'neutral baseline' of a round earth isn't just a fact—it's the foundational lie of a system that excludes them.

This is the sharp edge of the paradox. We want to be inclusive, but we don't want to build a bridge to a place we don't want go. Are we sitting down to build a shared reality (The Truth Table), or are we sitting down just to stop the fighting (The Relationship Table)?

Dr. Brianna J. Migliore's avatar

I see what you’re saying here, and I really appreciate the clarification on “unacceptable ideas.” I think your framing is very similar (if not the same) as what political psychology researchers call “sacred values,” which I’ve written about in the context of the persistence of the MAGA movement.

While I am a proponent of radical acceptance to some extent, Pearce Godwin’s idea that we could achieve peace by sacrificing democratic foundations seems both naive and short-sighted. I’m inclined to point to Karl Popper here again, who argued that if a society affords unlimited tolerance to the intolerant, we risk enabling intolerance as a norm and undermining the very concept of tolerance. I think the same is true for unity. If we sacrifice democracy in the pursuit of peace and unity, we undermine the very system that serves as the foundation for both.

I also appreciate the flat earther comparison (though I’ll admit that, as a scientist, it makes me bristle to even consider sacrificing evidence and shared reality in the name of unity). It actually makes me think of the response to the COVID pandemic, which had far more immediate and consequential implications than flat eartherism. We saw a significant breakdown of shared reality in the form of vaccine skepticism and broader science denial versus evidence-based public health interventions. If we consider that thought experiment and imagine conceding our evidence-based position in order to reduce conflict, perhaps we could have achieved more “unity.” But at what cost? Millions more deaths? Tens of millions? Hundreds of millions? What are we willing to sacrifice for unity?

From my perspective, I don’t think the goal should be unity at all. The goal should be harm reduction. In that sense, maybe what’s missing is a third frame entirely (The Harm Reduction Table). Sacrificing democratic foundations or shared reality in the name of peace might achieve short-term “unity,” but would likely destabilize the system and increase harm, especially over the long term. I guess the main dilemma here (that you’re pointing to) is what we choose when unity conflicts with things like truth and harm reduction. Personally, I may be willing to tolerate false beliefs in very limited cases where the harm is minimal (for example, a flat earther). But when unity and harm reduction conflict, I will always choose harm reduction.

That being said, I really appreciate this exchange. I’ve been circling these ideas for a while, and this has helped sharpen my thinking significantly. I’m looking forward to reading your upcoming pieces on this.

Dr. Brianna J. Migliore's avatar

If I had to summarize my view succinctly, it’s that unity is only valuable insofar as it reduces harm.

Unity is a tool. Harm reduction is the goal.

And not all tools are appropriate in all circumstances. It makes me think of the saying that when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. But in a functioning society, we have a full toolbox that can help us achieve harm reduction (unity and truth being two of those tools).

The question is when unity moves us closer to reducing harm, and when it pulls us further away.