Why Certainty Can Be Dangerous - A Chat with Ilana Redstone
Unlocking the Certainty Trap
Without a doubt, our latest episode of the Outrage Overload podcast promises to be one of our most thought-provoking yet. I had the pleasure of speaking with Dr. Ilana Redstone, a sociology professor at the University of Illinois and author of "The Certainty Trap." Dr. Redstone's extensive research in demography and sociology has provided her with unique insights into the impact of immigration on society. However, it’s her exploration of the assumptions and certainties shaping our beliefs that truly sets her apart.
From the moment our conversation began, it was clear that Dr. Redstone has a remarkable ability to push my thinking in new directions. My pre-drafted questions were quickly set aside as we delved into the heart of her ideas. Dr. Redstone introduced the concept of the "certainty trap," highlighting how absolute certainty in our beliefs can stifle intellectual growth and hinder healthy democratic discourse.
"Certainty is the thing that justifies outrage. Certainty that you're right, certainty that the other person is a horrible person."
Certainty can lead to the dismissal and demonization of those who hold differing opinions. Dr. Redstone’s insights shed light on the importance of intellectual humility and curiosity, urging us to question our assumptions and embrace ambiguity.
Our discussion took a deep dive into the complexities of moral and ethical issues, emphasizing that recognizing these complexities is crucial for fostering understanding and empathy. Dr. Redstone’s ideas challenge us to rethink the foundations of our beliefs. She reminds us that democracy relies on the belief that all individuals are capable of reasoned thought and understanding.
Dr. Redstone acknowledges that it can be very hard to recognize this certainty trap in ourselves, but she gives us the reasons to understand why it is so important.
“If you're literally ready to write off half of the country as idiots or horrible and hateful in some way, then how can you function?”
As we wrapped up our conversation, I felt a renewed sense of hope. Dr. Redstone’s perspective offers a roadmap for navigating the polarized world we live in today. By challenging our own thinking and striving to understand our limitations, we can contribute to a more reasoned and compassionate society.
I invite you to tune in to this enlightening episode. Dr. Redstone’s insights are sure to leave you with much to ponder and discuss.
Warm regards,
David Beckmeyer
Host and Creator
New This Week in Outrage Episode!
It’s everything the Outrage Overload podcast is not. It’s not edited. It’s not scripted. It’s lightly researched. It’s David and Lisa talking about this week in outrage, what was in the news, in the memes, and maybe finding some backstory with a humorous (at least to us) twist.
